The bad side
Ok, so last time I covered some examples of good comic book movies, now the bad ones.
It is always sad when a comic book movie fails, especially if the source material is good, point and case, Kick-Ass
Kick-Ass
I loved Kick-Ass when I read it, it is without a doubt a great story. The studios realized this, and tried to profit off it, before it even had an ending.
The first 75% of Kick-Ass is great, (except Nick Cage) and is some wonderful story telling. It just kept on getting better and better, the high point of the film being
(SPOILER) Nicolas Cage's death.
 |
Always the highlight of a Nicolas Cage film
|
Though Nicolas Cage aside, the movie managed to keep the somewhat brutal realism of the comics, no super powers or super technology happening.
In film, there is a thing called the circle of expectation. By the environment that surrounds the characters in a film we establish what their reality is, what is mundane, and what is impossible.
This tried and true method can help the audience believe the action on screen, even if it is a completely new environment.
But if you go outside the circe of expectations you betray the audience by being a lazy writer. Imagine if when Luke faced Vader on cloud city, Luke just glared and his enemy and turned him to stone, we would all be pissed off.
 |
Kinda like in Kick-Ass when...
|
Now, I am aware that it is hinted at before, but it still just was too far-fetched for me.
After a film where this kid is beat to nearly to death several times, where everything is realistic up until the point where this kid flies up in a jetpack with shoulder mounted mini guns. Then they proceed to fly around the city for what seems like 10 minutes, where as real jet pack can't even manage 30 seconds 10 feet from the ground.
If this kind of thing happened in Iron Man it would feel right in place, thats the kind of established world there is.
They just thought that this short of thing is cool, which it is no doubt, and the audience would not care because they are just a bunch of sweaty comic nerds who would be too busy thinking of ways to re-create it for PAX, than realize that it has no place in the story.
I for one will not fall prey.
Having said that, Kick-Ass is still not all that bad at all.
Some more that are not bad, just not fantastic
- X-men 3 - A very solid "mehhhh"
- Spider-man 3 - Still fun to watch, but has far too much going on in it to really get a feel for the character again
- Watchmen - A good film if you liked the source material, but alienating and confusing, and too slow paced for most audiences
- The Spirit - A good laugh if you go into it expecting one, it captured the pulp-ey feel of the spirit pretty well
Others that are just horrible
- Ghost Rider - Nicolas cage, nuff said
- Daredevil - Despite the fact that a blind person is the ideal role for Ben Affleck, this movie just did not turn out well
- Fantastic 4 - I can't even think of a creative way to say it sucks
- Hulk - The main problem here is that director Ang Lee made an art film, not a superhero flick
- X-men origins: Wolverine - They took the only thing attracting comic fans to the movie (Deadpool) and completely destroyed the character
- League of Extraordinary Gentlemen - While the comic was great. This is trash.